In commemoration of the thirtieth anniversary of the National Youth Symphony Orchestra “Libertador San Martín” and its recent inclusion in the National Stable Ensembles, Maestro Mario Benzecry shares reflections on this crucial investment in the future of youth and music.
Additionally, in our conversation, we look forward to the special concert on Saturday, March 30th at 7 pm at the National Auditorium of the CCK, with free admission, featuring the participation of nine former directors of the symphonic ensemble. At the end of the interview, Mariela Bolatti, National Director of Stable Ensembles, extends a warm welcome.
By Virginia Chacon Dorr
-If I ask you about the beginnings of the National Youth Symphony, the germinal ideas that shaped it. What is the first memory that comes to your mind?
-I believe there were two germinal ideas for the start of the Libertador San Martín Youth Symphony Orchestra. The furthest one dates back to 1954 when the Youth Symphony Orchestra of State Radio was created, and I was one of those who entered through a competition. I was the youngest; I was 17 years old when I joined the orchestra, and I must say it left a profound impact on me. Now, the most immediate antecedent happened in 1994, in February. I was in my home studio working when the phone rang: it was Maestro José Antonio Abreu, with whom I had been two weeks earlier doing concerts in Venezuela with the Simón Bolívar Orchestra and conducting courses for Venezuelan orchestra conductors. He asked me if I would dare to create a youth orchestra because he was with a group of young Argentinians who had traveled to learn about the system, and they had mentioned to him that in Buenos Aires, precisely with the closure of the State Radio orchestra (now Radio Nacional), they were left without orchestras to practice, to learn, to make music. So, I told him to put these young people in direct contact with me when they returned to Buenos Aires, and from there we would organize. Said and done. This group of young people were Marina and Ezequiel Calzado Linage. Marina, nowadays, is the director of the Astor Piazzolla Conservatory, and Ezequiel is a timpanist and percussionist, along with other musicians.
I met with this group and we started coordinating everything. Without having anything, no orchestra, no rehearsal space, no repertoire, nothing, I already scheduled the first concert. Through the efforts made to obtain venues, the concert was held at the Italian Club, which is in front of Parque Rivadavia. So, I asked them: How many kids do you think will come to the orchestra? And easily, 70, 75, they answered. For the first rehearsal, held at the Auditorium of the Mariano Moreno National School, where I had attended high school, 27 kids came. No, it wasn’t to discourage, but it was much less than what they had told me. Then, as rehearsals progressed, the word spread, and for that first concert, we were already 94. In that concert, Pablo Saraví, the great Argentine violinist, concertmaster of the Buenos Aires Philharmonic, acted as a soloist, and with his proverbial generosity, he came and played Max Bruch’s concerto with us.
A week before the concert, I called Maestro Abreu and told him that we were going to do the concert. The only response I got from him was, “I’ll go” and so he did, which led the Secretary of Culture of that time to also attend the concert. There were speeches where it seemed like the orchestra was being handed to us on a silver platter. Then, as it usually happens in our country, unfortunately, a few days later, they replaced the Secretary of Culture, who had other interests and knew nothing about this. We went 18 years without any support, neither state nor private. I used to say that we were a private orchestra… deprived of everything. And that was the genesis of the Libertador San Martín Youth Symphony, which has now become the National Youth Orchestra Libertador San Martín, under the Directorate of Stable Organizations of the Ministry of Human Capital.
-What values guided the continuity of this great Orchestra?
The orchestra survived without any contribution from anyone, except for some teachers occasionally facilitated by the Mozarteum Argentino, and a donation of instruments obtained by Maestro Abreu through UNESCO: they were the timpani, three double basses, a bass drum, and some other elements. Apart from this, the orchestra never received any support for 18 years. For 18 years, no child, no conductor, no one received any economic remuneration. The remuneration was artistic, spiritual, and that makes us believe a lot in our youth. Although there were many other small orchestras that received subsidies and offered fees, they preferred to come to this orchestra where they knew they could learn a repertoire that would serve them for a future in the great orchestras. Furthermore, there was a very nice atmosphere of cordiality, which continues to this day. That’s why I defined it as a half orchestra – half club. We always worked very seriously, but in a relaxed and friendly atmosphere. I must even say that lasting families have been formed from the orchestra. I am very happy about the atmosphere that was generated and that continues to this day. These have been the values that have guided us: artistic discipline, a high level, and a favorable working and learning environment, without forms of punishment or repression, but simply teaching.
These have been the values that have guided us: artistic discipline, a high level, and a favorable working and learning environment, without forms of punishment or repression, but simply teaching.
Maestro Mario Benzecry Tuit
-As you mentioned, the Orchestra has grown despite not always having the adequate resources. In this regard, what does it mean to become part of the Stable Ensembles?
-Entering the orbit of the National State, first as a subsidized program and as part of the National Directorate of Stable Ensembles and the Secretariat of Culture of the Ministry of Human Capital, meant for us a very important qualitative and quantitative change.
Quantitative, because the orchestra, when we entered the State, had 55 members. Nowadays, it has 86 scholarship recipients who receive a monthly stipend to cover the costs of studies and, in many cases, also minor repairs of their instruments (strings, reeds, etc.). On the other hand, qualitative, because with the increase in the number of members, we were able to tackle major repertoires ideal for facing the demands they would later have in the most important symphony orchestras in the country. Thus, we were able to perform works such as The Rite of Spring, Petrushka, The Firebird; some symphonies by Mahler like the first, second, fifth, and sixth; we also performed symphonies by Bruckner like the third, fourth, seventh, and soon the eighth. All this has made this orchestra become a preliminary stage to enter the professional ones. This is now linked to the fact that the National University of the Arts, through the Department of Musical and Sound Arts, has created the career for Orchestra Instrumentalist. I am very happy about this because it was my plan, a proposal that I brought to the university and was accepted very willingly. Currently, the young people in the orchestra have to complete three years of continuous work and three non-face-to-face subjects annually. After these three years, they become Technicians in Orchestra Instrumentalists. What importance does this have? On the one hand, having an official national university degree, even if it is undergraduate, gives them much greater self-esteem. On the other hand, if they enter a state orchestra, the degree means a 30% higher salary for them, precisely because they are titled instrumentalists.
All of this, I think, is part of our transition to the State, which has now been fully realized by becoming part of the National Directorate of Stable Ensembles. This means not the stability of each child in the orchestra, but the stability of the scholarships of the children in the orchestra. It means that this is an orchestra that has come to stay.
-If you had to briefly explain to someone the importance of the existence of orchestras like the National Youth Symphony “José de San Martín”, what would you say?
-I would tell them that this orchestra has three essential elements: an educational one, another social-labor one, and another cultural one. It is educational because it teaches young people to tackle the great works of our symphonic and operatic repertoire. In addition, we perform at least one opera during the year to prepare them for any orchestra. The second one is of a social-labor nature, as it offers them job opportunities; a large percentage of our young people win competitions in the main symphony orchestras in the country every year, which ensures them a permanent work and artistic life by entering the State through a competition, thus obtaining a lifetime appointment. Finally, in terms of the cultural element, there is the compensation they provide by organizing concerts, whether at the Faculty of Law, at the CCK, and many other places, including educational concerts to create new audiences. This orchestra created the audience at the Faculty of Law, which until 1994 – after the defunct State Radio Symphony Orchestras and Youth Radio Symphony Orchestras around 1960- had no music. We reopened it and created an audience, just as we did at the CCK. We have been closely linked to this cultural center from the beginning; we usually perform in the Symphony Hall, but we also inaugurated the Argentine Hall, an honor that was granted to us.
-Finally, what feelings does the upcoming anniversary concert of the 30 years of the National Youth Symphony evoke in you?
-It arouses in me a profound emotion. The celebration of the 30 years will be a concert full of reminiscence and nostalgia. All those assistant conductors who passed through the orchestra will participate. We have a director training program that has been going on for 7 or 8 years during which they are trained not only in conducting but also in matters related to the management and organization of a symphonic ensemble. We have directors who will conduct because they are more or less close, although some are not so close. There are people coming from Neuquén, like Andrés Tolcachir, or from Paraguay, like José Ramírez, who comes exclusively to conduct for a few minutes. Each one will conduct a work and will be accompanied by the concertmaster they had when they were in the orchestra. We have also called on former members who want and can form a mega-orchestra. It is so big that we will have to rotate so that everyone has the possibility of entering the stage at the CCK.
There are some conductors who cannot come for reasons, whether work-related or distance-related. This is the case of Debora Waldman, the first female conductor of a National Orchestra in France and current principal conductor of the Avignon National Orchestra, who was an assistant for three years in the orchestra. Pablo Boggiano will also not be present, a very frequent conductor of the National Symphony and the Philharmonic, who usually conducts in Vienna and Eastern European countries. Luis Belforte, the current principal conductor of the Bahía Blanca Orchestra, will also not be part of it.
Performers such as María Cecilia Muñoz will play; she is the flute teacher of the orchestra and at the same time was one of its members for several years. That is to say, she is someone who left the orchestra and then returned as a teacher. Ezequiel Fainguersch, the Calzado Linage brothers, the Nardozza sisters, all founders of the orchestra, Juan Bringas, one of the first concertmasters, will also be present. In other words, there will be a very exciting overview of the orchestra’s history through works that resonate with the audience, such as the Intermezzo from Cavalleria Rusticana, which will be conducted by Roberto Luvini, and then Finlandia by Sibelius conducted by Andrés Tolcachir. Afterwards, Abel Ghelman will conduct the Overture to The Marriage of Figaro. Ezequiel Silberstein will then lead the Rakoczy March from The Damnation of Faust by Berlioz. Then, Mariano Fidanza will conduct a bandoneon player. The orchestra does not have a bandoneon, it is a very strange and peculiar case. Esteban Ignacio Calderón, by the way, son of the great conductor Pedro Ignacio Calderón, started in the orchestra as a double bassist. He spent three years and then won a competition to become a double bassist in the San Juan Orchestra, and then switched to the bandoneon and is now a prominent solo bandoneon player. So much so that several years ago, he was with us at the CCK playing Piazzolla’s concerto, and this time he will be the soloist in Adiós Nonino.
María Clara Marco Fernández will conduct the Don Giovanni’s Overture by Mozart, José Ramírez will take charge of excerpts from Carmen by Bizet, and finally Agustín Tocalini will take the baton for the Turkish March from The Ruins of Athens by Beethoven and the Hungarian Dance No. 5 by Brahms. I will close the concert by conducting a premiere work, specially written for this occasion by Maestro Juan Carlos Figueiras, who has been one of the artists who has supported us the most from the Faculty of Law. This piece is called The Border, and we will end with the Radetzky March by Strauss. I think it’s a program deeply rooted in the public and that they will enjoy.
Words of welcome
We spoke with Mariela Bolatti, National Director of Stable Ensembles, who offered us some reflections on the inclusion of the San Martín Youth Orchestra in the National Ensembles.
“We are happy and celebrating doubly this month the great National Youth Symphony ‘Libertador San Martín’, led by the beloved Maestro Mario Benzecry, celebrates 30 years of history, and the celebration is twofold because in addition, this orchestra officially becomes part of the National Directorate of Stable Ensembles. We all know the trajectory of this symphonic group, we know about the vicissitudes, the difficulties, the fights, but also about the achievements of a formation that in its 30 years of existence has filled our country’s and foreign stages with music, education through art, and concerts. Many of us also know about its work as a School Orchestra, about the group of teenagers and young people who integrate year after year to take their first steps in this type of ensemble, about the example of seriousness and sustained work over time, about the consistency in supporting the work of young Argentine composers and conductors, about the ability to adapt to different languages, about the flexibility to cover both universal repertoires and very modern expressions of music. But simultaneously with that artistic excellence expressed on stage, we also know about this formative task that has been giving excellent results and delivering musicians and orchestra soloists, and even conductors, to symphonic bodies around the world. From this moment on, the Youth ‘José de San Martín’ becomes part of one of the most important spaces for music and dance in our country. In our direction are the best orchestral instrumentalists, the best choristers, the best dancers. I have the responsibility of leading a true National Selection of Music and Dance, and here, united with the rest of the ensembles, being part of a program of the highest level, the ‘Libertador San Martín’ will have its well-deserved space. I am sure that this change, this integration with the rest of the national ensembles, will mean an exponential growth for the orchestra, both in its artistic work on stage and in its formative and educational role. My greatest esteem, gratitude, and recognition to Maestro Benzecry and his beautiful and tireless work. Happy 30 years and welcome to the National Directorate of Stable Ensembles!“
My greatest esteem, gratitude, and recognition to Maestro Benzecry and his beautiful and tireless work. Happy 30 years and welcome to the National Directorate of Stable Ensembles!
Mariela Bolatti Tuit
About the concert
Ministry of Human Capital, National Ministry of Culture, National Directorate of Stable Ensembles
30th Anniversary Concert of the National Youth Symphony Orchestra Libertador San Martín
– Date and Time: Saturday, March 30th, 7:00 PM
– Venue: National Auditorium I CCK (Kirchner Cultural Centre), Autonomous City of Buenos Aires, Argentina
– Admission: Free
Participants:
– Principal Conductor: Maestro Mario Benzecry
– Guest Conductors:
– Roberto Luvini
– Andrés Tolcachir
– Abel Ghelman
– Ezequiel Silberstein
– Mariano Fidanza
– José Ramirez Duarte
– Maria Clara Marco Fernández
– Agustín Tocalini
– Soloist: Esteban Calderón (Bandoneón)
Program:
First Part:
– Pietro Mascagni – Intermezzo from Cavalleria Rusticana (Conductor: Roberto Luvini)
– Jean Sibelius – Finlandia (Conductor: Andrés Tolcachir)
– Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart – Overture from The Marriage of Figaro (Conductor: Abel Ghelman)
– Hector Berlioz – Rakoczy March (The Damnation of Faust Op. 24) (Conductor: Ezequiel Silberstein)
– Astor Piazzolla (Arranged by J. Bragato) – Adios Nonino (Conductor: Mariano Fidanza)
– Soloist: Esteban Calderón (Bandoneón)
Second Part:
– Georges Bizet – Prelude, Seguidilla, and Toreadors from the Suite “Carmen” (Conductor: José Ramirez Duarte)
– Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart – Overture from Don Giovanni (Conductor: Maria Clara Marco Fernández)
– Ludwig van Beethoven – Turkish March from “The Ruins of Athens” (Op. 113)
– Johannes Brahms – Hungarian Dance No. 5 (Conductor: Agustín Tocalini)
– Juan Figueiras – The Border (World Premiere)
– Johann Strauss – Radetzky March (Op. 238) (Principal Conductor: Mario Benzecry)